We decided to pass by the Boatyard yesterday evening for pizza and beer.
They have one of the nicer thin crust pizzas on the island, and the prices (EC$30-40) are quite reasonable.

The Boatyard is a nice place to just hangout and enjoy a meal or a few beers. They have an outside bar and benches, if you don't wish to sit at a table, but everything is quite casual.

Music is not too loud, so conversation is not a struggle.
Overall, a nice relaxing place which tends to be a favourite with yachties and many locals.

This time around, we both enjoyed the fish pizza (although I wouldn't have minded a few slices of pineapple on it) - good, without leaving you too stuffed.
Left room for some ice cream (yes, they have an assortment of flavours to choose from).

The Boatyard
Prickly Bay
Lance Aux Epines
Phone 473/444-4662